Whole Life Insurance After 10 Years: What You Can Do Now

Whole Life Insurance After 10 Years: What You Can Do Now

Many people don’t start thinking seriously about life insurance until they hit a major milestone—marriage, children, a health scare, or their 40s. That’s why it’s notable when someone starts paying $500/month into a whole life insurance policy in their early 20s, especially with no kids or spouse at the time.

And that’s exactly what one now-32-year-old did. For the past 10 years, he’s been consistently funding a whole life policy and only now—after a full decade—is the policy’s cash value finally breaking even.

It’s a scenario that might sound familiar to many, but it also opens up a larger conversation:

  • Did he start too early?
  • Was it the wrong product?
  • What should he do now?
  • And what lessons can other people learn from this?

Let’s break it down.

Starting Young Wasn’t a Mistake—It Was a Head Start

Here’s the reality: most people don’t think about life insurance at 22 or 23. They’re just graduating college, getting their first job, maybe dealing with student loans or saving for an apartment.

So starting any policy at that age—especially something as long-term and commitment-heavy as whole life—is unusual, but it’s not a bad thing.

In fact, it comes with benefits:

  • Locking in lower premiums: Age and health are major factors in pricing. Starting young typically means you’re getting one of the most affordable rates you’ll ever qualify for.
  • Giving cash value time to grow: The earlier you start, the more time compound interest and dividends have to do their work.
  • Setting the foundation for advanced strategies: By 32, this person now has a financial tool most people his age haven’t even heard of, let alone built up.

Sure, the first 8–10 years can feel like a slow grind. But now that the policy has broken even, it’s entered its most powerful phase.

The Real Frustration: Lack of Financial Guidance

One of the most relatable parts of this story is that despite having a strong income, job stability, and no consumer debt, this individual still felt lost when it came to personal finance.

He said it himself:

"I was under the naive opinion until recently that 'at least I have been doing something to save for retirement.'"

This isn’t about a bad decision—it’s about a lack of accessible, unbiased guidance. That’s a challenge many people face. Financial literacy isn’t a default skill—it’s something you have to actively seek out, and most don’t have mentors, educators, or fiduciary advisors early on.

But the upside?

This person now understands the importance of taking action—and he’s still young enough to course-correct without missing a beat.

You’re in a Good Spot—Here’s How to Maximize It

This situation isn’t a financial failure. It’s a launch point. Here's what we recommend thinking about:

Leverage the Policy, Don’t Abandon It

You’ve done the hard part—paying in for 10 years. Now it’s time to let the dividends and cash value start working for you. Some options:

  • Use dividends to offset future premiums
  • Take a policy loan for investments or emergencies
  • Use it as a tax-free retirement supplement later
  • Leave it in place to provide long-term life insurance protection for your family

2. Consider Adding a Term Policy

Now that you’re married with two young kids, your insurance needs have changed. Whole life is great for permanence—but you may also need higher short-term coverage. A 30-year term policy can be a low-cost way to protect your family during your highest earning years.

3. Look Into a 1035 Exchange

If you decide the whole life policy no longer fits your goals, you don’t have to cash it out and trigger taxes. A 1035 exchange allows you to roll it into another tax-advantaged product, such as a variable annuity with guaranteed income benefits.

4. Boost Your 401(k) Contributions

Yes, your Roth 401(k) could be higher. But contributing 3% is still better than nothing. Start small and ramp up:

  • Increase 1% every 6–12 months
  • At minimum, contribute enough to get your full employer match
  • Diversify your investments with age-appropriate risk allocation

What's Happening in the Market Right Now?

Here’s why this conversation is especially relevant today:

  • Annuities are gaining popularity as more people seek stable, guaranteed income outside the volatile stock market.
  • Interest in life insurance with living benefits—like cash value and accelerated death benefits—is growing, especially among millennials.
  • The Federal Reserve has paused rate hikes, making now a strategic time to review long-term financial products tied to interest rates.

Meanwhile, insurance companies continue to pivot back toward long-term policies that offer lifetime value—not just term coverage.

Our Take as a Farmers Insurance Agency

At our Farmers Insurance agency in Ontario, CA, we’ve seen both sides:

  • People who waited too long and are now dealing with higher premiums
  • People who started early but never learned how to use their policy to its full potential

If you’re somewhere in between, we’re here to help you make sense of your options.

Whether it’s understanding how your current policy works, exploring term life, or building a complete plan that ties your life insurance, retirement savings, and financial goals together—we’ll walk you through it.

Ready to Review Your Life Insurance Strategy?

We’re licensed to serve clients across California and offer a free, no-obligation quote—whether you're reviewing an existing whole life policy or exploring your options for the first time.

If you’ve had a whole life policy for 10 years, let’s talk about how to make it work harder for you. If you’re just getting started, we’ll help you choose the right coverage based on your goals—not just a sales pitch.

Get your free life insurance quote today. No pressure. No obligation. Just clear answers.

Back to blog