Car Insurance in California Is Getting Out of Hand
If you're shopping for car insurance in California right now, the quotes you're seeing probably feel like a punch in the gut.
$230+ per month for a single vehicle?
Two-week wait times to even activate coverage?
Quotes jumping from $180 to $270 overnight?
Unfortunately, you're not imagining it. You're watching the result of multiple insurance industry problems collide at once—right here in California.
What's Causing the Spike?
There’s no single reason—it’s a pile-up:
- Insurance carriers weren’t allowed to raise rates during the pandemic, so now they’re playing catch-up.
- California just approved over $1 billion in premium increases across the top six insurance companies. That includes Geico, Mercury, Allstate, and yes—Farmers.
- Modern cars are more expensive to repair, thanks to tech-heavy builds, sensors, and cameras.
- High-risk models, especially some Kia and Hyundai vehicles, have pushed theft rates up statewide.
- Bad drivers and more accidents mean higher payouts for insurers—costs they’re passing onto everyone.
And according to the California Department of Insurance, drivers can expect average annual rate increases like:
- $125 more per year for Geico
- $80 more per vehicle with Mercury
- $98 more per year for Farmers customers
- $167 annual hike for Allstate
- $71 more per year on average for State Farm policyholders
This is on top of the already high monthly average of $260+ for auto insurance in California.
Why Some Carriers Make You Wait 14–30 Days
That two-week or even one-month waiting period? It's not a glitch—it’s underwriting.
Some carriers, like Geico and State Farm, use a 14-day delay to process and verify your information. Others, like Progressive and Allstate, stretch that to 30 days. It’s not law—it’s strategy. And it’s become standard practice in California due to strict state regulations and overwhelmed systems.
What Drivers Are Saying
We’ve heard it all lately:
- A clean-driving, low-mileage customer quoted $270/month by AAA, up from $180 just a year ago
- That same customer switched to Mercury and got back down to $180—on two vehicles
- Others with new cars and perfect records are being quoted $230–$270+ with basic coverage
- Some customers are just waiting weeks for approval letters to show up in the mail before they can even lock in a policy
The market is unpredictable. The prices feel random. And for most drivers, it’s just frustrating.
What You Can Actually Do About It
Now’s the time to be proactive. Here’s how you take control:
Work with a licensed agency (like us)
We’re not just quoting one carrier—we help customers across California find affordable car insurance in California with the right combination of coverage, carrier, and price.
Don’t just chase the cheapest number
State minimum coverage may look like a deal—but one accident could leave you paying thousands out of pocket. You need the right coverage, not just the cheapest one.
Re-shop your policy
Even if you got a good rate last year, it may no longer be competitive. Things have changed fast. We can help you run multiple quotes based on your vehicle, driving history, mileage, and area.
Watch out for high-risk vehicle types
Cars like certain Hyundais and Kias may now trigger higher rates automatically, even with good driving records. Newer vehicles with high repair costs? Same story.
Consider usage-based programs
If you're driving under 7,000 miles per year, ask us about low-mileage or telematics options that may bring your rate down.
Don’t forget the smaller carriers
In some cases, smaller or regional insurers not getting hit as hard may offer better rates and faster turnaround. We’ll show you all the options—not just the big names.
Tired of the Rate Rollercoaster?
We get it. And we can help.
We’re a Farmers Insurance agency based in Ontario, California, licensed to serve drivers anywhere in the state. Whether you’re overwhelmed by rising rates, stuck in a 30-day delay, or just want to compare your options—we’re here to help.
Get real answers. Fast turnaround. And support from an actual person who knows the system.
Looking for affordable car insurance in California?
Want free car insurance quotes?
Start here. Call, text, or request a quote today—we’ll make it simple.