What’s Next for Medicare Advantage Under Trump?

What’s Next for Medicare Advantage Under Trump?

Medicare is a federal health insurance program for people 65 and older and certain younger individuals with disabilities. It comes in two primary forms: Original Medicare, a government-run system covering hospital and medical services, and Medicare Advantage (MA), a privatized option where beneficiaries receive coverage through insurance companies.

With Donald Trump’s return to the White House, the future of Medicare Advantage is once again in question. The administration has sent mixed signals about whether it will expand the program or cut spending to reduce federal costs. Insurance companies, providers, and—most importantly—Medicare beneficiaries are watching closely.

Will Medicare Advantage Face Cuts?

Right now, the biggest question is whether Trump will push more seniors into Medicare Advantage while simultaneously cutting funding to the insurers that run these plans. His administration has floated ideas such as:

  • "Medicare Advantage for All" – a proposal to automatically enroll beneficiaries in MA unless they opt for traditional Medicare.
  • Cutting “waste, fraud, and abuse” – a vague but potentially severe reduction in Medicare spending.
  • Investigating insurer overpayments – the Trump Justice Department is already probing UnitedHealthcare’s billing practices for Medicare Advantage.

With Elon Musk advising Trump on federal spending, the pressure to cut Medicare’s budget is growing. Musk has proposed slashing $2 trillion from government programs, and since Medicare makes up 15% of federal spending, it’s a prime target.

Medicare Advantage: Better Care or Bigger Profits?

Proponents of Medicare Advantage argue that private insurers streamline care, improve coordination, and offer benefits that traditional Medicare lacks, such as:

  • Dental and vision coverage
  • Gym memberships
  • Prescription drug benefits

However, some studies suggest these plans are more expensive for taxpayers, costing 20% more per patient than traditional Medicare. Insurance companies maximize profits through risk adjustments, where they claim higher reimbursements for sicker patients—sometimes by over-diagnosing conditions.

If Trump’s team decides to cut funding to these plans, insurers may respond by:

  • Reducing extra benefits like dental, vision, and gym memberships.
  • Lowering payments to hospitals and skilled nursing facilities.
  • Shortening hospital stays for patients, making care access more difficult.

Medicare Insurance in the 2024 Election

The debate over Medicare insurance isn’t happening in a vacuum. In recent news, Trump’s 2025 budget proposal is expected to include broad spending cuts, sparking fears about potential reductions to Medicare and Social Security.

Meanwhile, the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) has warned that Medicare Advantage is costing taxpayers too much. Their recommendation? Limit how much the government pays insurers. If that happens, it could mean higher premiums or fewer benefits for millions of seniors.

The Bottom Line

Medicare Advantage is popular but expensive. If Trump slashes funding, expect fewer benefits and stricter provider networks. If he expands MA, insurers will gain more control over senior healthcare—but at what cost?

For now, Medicare beneficiaries should stay informed, compare plans carefully, and prepare for potential changes ahead.

Back to blog